MARY ANN POLL

Why a Christian Tells True Ghost Stories

Most weeks, I keep company with things that go bump in the night. Lately that has meant a ghost who came back from the grave because the gifts in his will were never paid, a spirit that promised to wreck a priest’s car and kept its promise, and a farmhouse kitchen where 2 sides of bacon came down out of the chimney and settled on a pan of scalding milk. I’m still not sure whether that last one was a haunting or a very confused breakfast.

So it’s a fair question. What is a woman of faith doing with all of this?

Here’s the honest answer. I don’t tell these stories because darkness fascinates me. I tell them because darkness is real, and the light is stronger. Pretending the dark isn’t there has never made anyone safer. Scripture doesn’t tiptoe around evil. It names it plainly, and then it shows us what is stronger.

That’s what I find in nearly every true account I research. In 1928, in a little farm town in Iowa, a whole parish gathered to pray for a woman in torment. In 1683, a country minister in Devon gave a frightened mother advice that still holds up: write down everything that is happening, and get your son out of that house. Even in the oldest, strangest records, someone is reaching for the light.

I don’t tell these stories because darkness fascinates me. I tell them because darkness is real, and the light is stronger.

I also tell them because they’re true, and truth matters to me. Every episode starts with the oldest record I can find: a minister’s letter, a sworn statement, a priest’s own account. If a detail can’t be documented, it doesn’t go in. That rule has cost me some wonderful legends. But the truth is usually stranger anyway. Nobody could invent a ghost who insists his debts be paid. Apparently even the dead can’t stand an unpaid bill.

The old records have their own sense of humor, too. They can’t always agree on how to spell people’s names. One poor young man from 1682 appears as Fey, Fry, and Pry, depending on who was holding the pen. If he’s haunting anyone today, I hope it’s the clerks.

Some moments in the record are hard to read without a smile. In 1683, that same young man was carried up into the air on Easter Eve. His family found him half an hour later, sitting in a bog and singing. The next morning, they found his wig hanging at the top of a tall tree. I’ve had bad hair days, but never one quite like that. Still, I never forget that these were real people. Their fear was real, and so was their courage.

There’s something else these stories do. They remind us that fear has been around a lot longer than the evening news. Families in 1682 heard noises in the dark and wondered what was there, just as some of us do now. And they found their way through it the same way we can: by praying, by holding on to each other, and by trusting that God has not left us alone.

So if you’ve ever felt a little guilty for loving a good ghost story, you’re in fine company. Pour a cup of something warm, pull your chair a little closer to the lamp, and come listen. You’ll find Real Ghost Chatter on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube, and in every one of these true stories, you’ll see the same thing I do. The darkness never gets the last word.

“The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.” John 1:5 (NIV)

Mary Ann Poll is an independent author known as America’s Lady of Supernatural Thrillers. She writes the six-book Ravens Cove Iconoclast series, supernatural thrillers where the darkness is real but the light is stronger still, and hosts Real Ghost Chatter, a weekly podcast of true supernatural stories. Find her books at maryannpoll.com, on Amazon.com, or wherever good books are sold.

Still hungry? Here’s more

Send Mary Ann A Note

Mary Ann A Bio

Mary Ann Poll, America’s Lady of Supernatural Thrillers, is the award-winning author of the Ravens Cove series. Born in Texas and shaped by its wide skies and stubborn spirit, Mary Ann called Alaska home for over forty years — and though her boots are back on Texas soil, her heart never left the Last Frontier. That love for both lands breathes through every page — from the sun-baked spirit of Texas to the eerie perpetual light of the Alaskan solstice and the rich traditions of Alaska’s Indigenous peoples.

Her love for a spine-tingling story and her love for Christ come together in her writing. Mary Ann’s own spiritual journey — from a lifelong fascination with the supernatural to a deep and abiding faith — gives her novels their distinctive voice: suspenseful, grounded in real spiritual stakes, and rooted in hope.

When she’s not writing, Mary Ann enjoys gardening, swimming, and time with her beloved family and pets — who have a habit of finding their way into her stories.